Monday, September 21, 2020

A resolution from the Democratic Committee about Eurie Stamps

 

From the Source:

FRAMINGHAM – The Framingham Democratic Committee is calling for the Framingham police officer who killed Eurie Stamps Sr. in 2011 to be fired from the City of Framingham’s police department and for police officers in the schools to be removed.

In a resolution approved Sunday,Septemebr 13, the Framingham Democratic Committee, called for an independent review board to be created to review complaints about police actions and make recommendations to city officials.

The resolution called the killing of Mr. Stamps, 68, in a raid by Framingham Police in 2011, “an example of unacceptable police violence that remains without consequences to the officer who shot him.” Mr. Stamps was not a suspect in any crime, and was following police orders, laying on his stomach on the floor of his home, when officer Paul Duncan shot him in the head. The Middlesex DA later ruled the shooting an accident. #JusticeForEurie have demanded a new investigation into the shooting.

SOURCE

“The death of Eurie Stamps has not been adequately addressed by the City of Framingham and the officer responsible for the death of Mr. Stamps remains on active duty as a member of the Framingham Police Department,” the resolution states.  It calls for the city to “acknowledge that the tragic death of Eurie Stamps is indicative of bias and general lack of empathy toward Black and Brown communities; that excessive use of force is too often reserved for such communities and must end; and that Paul Duncan, the Police Officer who fired the fatal shot and was allowed to remain on the Framingham Police Dept., be dismissed from said Department.”

The resolution recognized the work of the Framingham High School Black Student Union, which has complained that students find the presence of police officers in school intimidating. It calls for money spent on school resource officers be reallocated toward “qualified community and psychological health workers for deployment into the schools to address psycho/social and substance-related issues in our student population.”

 The resolution will be delivered to Mayor Yvonne Spicer, 11-member City Council, 9-member School Committee, state legislators, Massachusetts Attorney General Maura Healey and Middlesex District Attorney Marian Ryan.

 Resolution Pertaining to Racial Equity and Social Justice Framingham Democratic Committee September 13, 2020


WHEREAS, race-based violence by police officers against Black and Brown people throughout our country continue to create terror in communities of Color with little or no consequences to the police officers; and

WHEREAS, the killing of Eurie Stamps on January 5, 2011 by a Framingham Police Officer is an example of unacceptable police violence that remains without consequences to the officer who shot him; and

WHEREAS, the untimely and tragic death of Eurie Stamps was the result of the militarization of the Framingham Police Department, who dispatched a SWAT team to arrest an individual alleged to have committed a non-violent drug offense; and

WHEREAS, Mr. Stamps was not a suspect. He was shot and killed while lying on the floor in his home, unarmed, non-threatening, and in full compliance with officers who knew him and that he was innocent; and


WHEREAS, the death of Eurie Stamps has not been adequately addressed by the City of Framingham and the officer responsible for the death of Mr. Stamps remains on active duty as a member of the Framingham Police Department; and WHEREAS, the Framingham High School Black Student Union (BSU) has indicated that the presence of School Resource [Police] Officers in our public schools is intimidating to the students; and


WHEREAS, the BSU believes social justice programs and services to Black and Brown students should reflect an investment in their wellbeing, without the perception of criminality; and

WHEREAS, the Black Lives Matter movement continues to advocate for non-violent protest against police brutality and significantly elevates awareness of the shameful institutional and systemic racism found in our country and community.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED:

The Framingham Democratic Committee calls for immediate action to be taken by the appropriate authorities, including:

  1. That the Legislature establish a state-wide independent review board similar to the one described in H2068 to review complaints emanating from police actions or procedures and to take appropriate actions based on its findings;
  2. That until a state-wide independent review board is established, the City of Framingham establish its own independent board to review complaints and evidence emanating from actions and procedures of Framingham Police Officers and, based on its findings, to make appropriate recommendations to the Chief of Police, the Mayor, and City Council;
  1. That the City of Framingham formalize its commitment to diversity and inclusion in its Police Department so that it more accurately reflects the city’s diverse population;
  2. That the City of Framingham formalize its policy of requiring the widespread use of body cameras for police;
  3. That the Legislature reform the judicial doctrine of “qualified immunity” by denying its use unless a Police Officer can show that his or her conduct was reasonable under the circumstances, even in novel cases where the law is not clearly established;
  4. That police officers and assistant district attorneys be prohibited from applying for a “no knock” warrant without first obtaining approval by the District Attorney;
  5. That the City of Framingham acknowledge that the tragic death of Eurie Stamps is indicative of bias and general lack of empathy toward Black and Brown communities; that excessive use of force is too often reserved for such communities and must end; and that Paul Duncan, the Police Officer who fired the fatal shot and was allowed to remain on the Framingham Police Dept., be dismissed from said Department; and
  6. That funding now applied to the School Resource Officers be reallocated and used in the hiring and retention of qualified community and psychological health workers for deployment into the schools to address psycho/social and substance-related issues inour student population.

14 Comments:

At September 21, 2020 at 4:56 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

This all sounds good but are there any teeth in this to actually make something happen or is this just another feel good type of thing that accomplishes nothing?

 
At September 22, 2020 at 12:36 PM , Blogger Jim Pillsbury said...

It is a non-binding resolution. No one HAS to act, but you can bet this subject is not going away any time soon. As we learn about another black man beaten by 5 Framingham Officers 8 years ago. The State's highest court ruled that the convicted defendant can sue the city for violating his civil rights. All of those same cops are still on the force.

 
At September 23, 2020 at 1:09 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Systemic problems appear to exist on the Framingham police, but no one cares enough to do anything about it. What the hell are they thinking? How many lawsuits is the city going to have to pay with our tax dollars before they address this issue?

 
At September 23, 2020 at 1:12 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

The previous poster raised a good point. Any way to find out how many complaints about our police have ended up in court, and of those, how many have we lost? I know about the Stamps case, but given what I am hearing I suspect that is not the only one. Jim, can you find that out and share publicly? And do these payouts come out of tax payers dollars? If not and they are covered by insurance, how much has our insurance gone up because of the amount of money and/or the number of cases that have resulted in Framingham losing? Is any of this available to the public?

 
At September 23, 2020 at 3:08 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Interesting that after all these years the dems are weighing in. It begs the question what where they doing for the last 9 years and why is this suddenly something they think they have any say in?

 
At September 23, 2020 at 3:12 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Did you see this Jim?

https://www.metrowestdailynews.com/news/20200912/opiniondeeley-accountability-as-well-as-justice

This woman writes some pretty interesting columns for the League of Women voters.

 
At September 23, 2020 at 8:42 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

When r they presenting this 2 the DC?

 
At September 24, 2020 at 2:14 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

In light of the breanna Taylor decision yesterday do you think this might have ore traction to actually make changes?

 
At September 24, 2020 at 5:07 PM , Blogger jim pillsbury said...

Steph Deeley is my partner of 13 years and an excellent writer, grandmother, co-president of the League of Women Voters and all around good egg.

I presume the resolution will be voted on by the council next week.

That news about the failure of the AG to charge any of those cops will light a fire in Tennessee, but I'm afraid it won't do much here in the Ham. The Mayor is in the middle of deciding who to pick as Police Chief and unless Marion Ryan or Maura Healey charge Duncan with something, I just don't think the Mayor has the political will to force Duncan out. I wish I was wrong, but what's in it for her? But who knows, that Reading cop that shot someone back in 2018 is now charged so there may be hope.

 
At September 24, 2020 at 5:14 PM , Blogger jim pillsbury said...

I'm not sure about the legal status of any action against the City. A few years back, the legal budget had increased in general, but I haven't read anything about settlements. Keep in mind, anyone who wins a case against Framingham is most likely as part of the settlement is under a gag order not to discuss.


This from the Source:

Framingham Friends Meeting (Quaker) has reviewed the use of force statistics provided by the Framingham Police Department for the years 2016 on.

We were surprised and disturbed to learn that in most of the years reviewed there was a significant disparity in the use of force with African Americans as compared to their presence in the Framingham population (approximately 7%).

Specifically: in 2016, of the 38 reported use of force incidents, 15 involved African Americans or 39% of the total; in 2019, 21% of these incidents involved African Americans; and in the first quarter of 2020, that number rose to 33%.

We have followed up with acting Chief Brandolini of the Framingham Police Department and although very cooperative in looking into the details, he was unable to explain the disparity.

It had been our hope that the Police Advisory Committee would find the statistics as disturbing as we did.

At both the August meeting this year and at a subsequent meeting this month, their response was muted at best.

We had expected that this committee would take up the concern and wish to follow-up with the Police Department.

They were clear that they did not consider this to be their responsibility but the responsibility of a Police Oversight Committee.

 
At October 1, 2020 at 12:32 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Jim do you know what happened when this went before the district council for support?

 
At October 1, 2020 at 1:25 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Anyone see the police response in the Source today to Rick Holmes story about that latest case against the FPD? Interesting that is was sent to the Source, and not to the MW Daily News where Holmes story ran. Guess the police know that the Source leans towards them but it also shows that the Police Union that sent the letter to the Source recognizes that every, including Source readers, reads the MW Daily News. I they didn't read MWD they would have no ideas what their letter was talking about. Go MWD.

 
At October 1, 2020 at 3:38 PM , Blogger jim pillsbury said...

I was surprised to see that in the source today. And it changes nothing as far as I concerned. The truth will come out in the civil trial. I just may write a piece about how many FPD employee's and no longer employee's are on the Brady List. Susan is heavily weighted towards the cops and firemen, it's the most popular way to be.


 
At October 1, 2020 at 3:46 PM , Blogger jim pillsbury said...

It was approved by the CC last night as a resolution. That and a 1.50 will get you coffee at dunkin.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home